Rethinking the Annual Review

October 27, 2016

An employee review process is crucial to giving employees feedback on their performance. But the traditional annual review is becoming a thing of the past.

Blog Post
BLOG Rethinktheannualreviewtorevitalizeperformancemanagement 476971415 (1)

Businesses around the country are scrutinizing annual employee performance reviews. Some call them outdated and ineffectual.

“It’s not surprising that many organizations are continually updating and revising their performance management systems in an effort to achieve better results and improve fairness and accuracy,” writes Rick Lepsinger for Business2Community.

Still, keeping some form of the employee review process is crucial to offering your workers insight and allowing them to share their own feedback with managers about how they can contribute.

So how can you make sure to squeeze all the value out of your performance management process while leaving the dusty, we’ve-always-done-it-this-way attitude behind?

One idea: shake up the timing and frequency of your reviews. They can happen more than once a year.

“Requiring or encouraging managers to conduct periodic check-in meetings ties directly to the perception that the system helps employees build their skills and competencies — a key driver of fairness, accuracy and overall value to the business,” Lepsinger writes. “It also increases the likelihood that the annual performance review discussion will be a productive dialogue, versus a surprise.”

Or, consider pulling more people into each review.

“A comprehensive performance review that includes other people the employee works with can help create a more rounded picture of employee performance,” writes George N. Root III for the Houston Chronicle. “Managers and employees in other departments with whom the employee does business on a regular basis and some of the employee’s peers within the office can offer insight that is valuable to an effective performance evaluation.”

And, as you do, keep the end goal in mind, write Tom Cooney and Crystal Faulkner for

“It is crucial to have employees that provide quality work and help a business improve its odds of success,” they write. “The goal of any performance review should be to effectively communicate performance while simultaneously providing general guidance and updates on talent development.”


Date Posted: October 27, 2016

011002000104A Workforcemanagement Smalltiled (1) Copy

Max Productivity 

Get out of time-consuming processes while knowing your employees are set up for day-to-day success.

Manage with Confidence
011002000102A Humanresources Smalltiled

Modern HR Tools

Recruit and retain talent by shaping an environment that makes employees feel valued and engaged. Let our HR tools help.

Explore HR Solutions
Request a Demo